I loved you since I knew you
I wouldn't talk down to you
I have to tell you just how I feel
I was lying with another boy

The story:

I never really had an embarrassing moment, I just always thought that was how it went and thought that it was odd he liked a boy and also liked this girl. Still, years after the song wasn't played much I heard it again and it dawned on me what he was saying, but I still sing it as "Lying with another boy."