I will put a frog in your peanut butter

The story:

I was really little and my parents had it on music videos and I heard that song and thought he said "I will put a frog in your peanut butter" so I went around singing that. My mom tried to correct me, but I was convinced that he wanted to put a frog in our peanut butter. It wasn't until years later I finally listened. Now my friend and I both agree that "putting a frog in your peanut butter" sounds like a sexual innuendo.