that night, the sun in the trees made the skyline look like crooked
teeth in the mouth of a man swallowing a spoon

The story:

I was at a friend's party, singing along to the song quite loudly. My
friend gives me a really strange look, says, "It's 'us both.'" I argued
vehemently with another friend to back me up. We finally had to
settle the argument by Googling the lyrics.